Copart vs IAAI vs Manheim - which auction to choose

When we plan to bring a car from America, the first question that comes to us is: at which auction should we buy the car? In 2026, three major players will still lead the market: Copart, IAAI and Manheim. Each of them has its own specifics, advantages and disadvantages. This article will help you make the right choice.

Copart: the most popular and affordable

Copart is the most famous auto auction used by Georgians. Its main advantage is accessibility and intuitive interface. Cars with salvage and clean title are sold here. Most cars on Copart are sold by insurance companies, but you'll also find private sellers and dealers. It is always recommended to select vehicles sold by the insurance company in the filters to avoid hidden defects. For more information on how this platform works, see our guide: How to buy a car on Copart.

IAAI (Insurance Auto Auctions): A more reliable alternative?

IAAI is often considered Copart's main competitor, and according to some experienced dealers, cars are sold here in more realistic condition. IAAI is mainly operated by insurance companies and there are fewer so-called Number of cars "done" (with disguised damage). However, registering and managing an account on IAAI is a bit more complicated than on Copart. In addition, auction fees may vary slightly.

Manheim: auction for dealers and undamaged cars only

Manheim is radically different from Copart and IAAI. Mainly undamaged, used cars (Clean Title) are sold here, which are sold by banks, leasing companies and car dealerships. The main barrier is that an individual cannot register on Manheim. Only licensed dealers have access there. Therefore, if you want to buy a car in Manheim, you will definitely need the help of an intermediary company. Cars are much more expensive here, but you buy a car that doesn't need repairs and you can start using it right away.

Which one to choose? Summary

If you are looking for the cheapest possible car and ready to repair it - Copart is the best option. If you want a little more credibility from insurance companies - IAAI should be preferred. If you want a car without damage and you have more budget - Manheim is an ideal choice.

Don't forget that no matter which auction you choose, the shipping process is the same. Our company will help you at every stage. See our service: Auction Logistics and Marketing.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. Can I buy a car on my own in Manheim?

No, Manheim is a private auction for licensed car dealers only. You will definitely need the help of the dealer company.

2. Which auction has a higher fee?

Fees for Copart and IAAI are roughly the same and depend on the value of the vehicle. Fees at Manheim may be slightly higher. Read more: Hidden Auction Fees.

3. Are there any "clean" cars on Copart?

Yes, there are Clean Title vehicles on Copart, however most still carry some type of minor damage (eg hail, minor scratches) or are bank repossessed.

4. Which platform has the better mobile app?

Both platforms, Copart and IAAI, have very sophisticated mobile applications from which you can participate in live auctions.